Join UsCEO MastermindAI Leadership MastermindExecutive AI ProgramFractional AI ExecutiveFractional Advisory1:1 Coaching5-Minute Leader
BooksPower Without PermissionAI Leadership Mastermind
PodcastMeet the Team
ResourcesBlogFree Courses5-Minute Leader AcademyFree AssessmentsResearch and DataTeaching PackagesTestimonialsCEO Coaching ReportGuest Post NetworkJoin UsAdd us on Google

The Peter Principle: Why the Best Salesperson Becomes a Bad Manager, and the Five Minute Fix

The Peter principle in 40 words, the 1969 book and the 2019 sales study that confirmed it, three ways it shows in a company, and the first time manager fix.

By Andreas Pettersson, Founder, Leaders ADAPT

The Peter principle is the only management idea that started as a joke, got confirmed by economists fifty years later, and still runs every promotion meeting I sit in. The best salesperson becomes the sales manager. The best engineer runs engineering. Six months later both are miserable and so are their teams.

This page is the definition, the book, the 2019 study that proved the mechanism, three versions I see in companies, and what to do in the first 90 days so the principle stops applying to you.

I run Leaders ADAPT and wrote the 5-Minute Leader for the person the principle just promoted. I was that person once, at 29, running a company that grew past 150 people.

Leaders ADAPT on the Peter Principle: The Peter principle says people in a hierarchy are promoted on current performance until they reach a job they cannot do, and stay there. Peter and Hull wrote it as satire in 1969. In 2019 Benson, Li and Shue confirmed it in sales data: the best sellers were promoted most and managed worst. The fix is to treat the first 90 days as a new job, with a method.

The Peter principle, defined

The Peter principle is the observation that in a hierarchy, people tend to be promoted on the basis of success in their current role until they reach a role in which they are no longer competent, where they remain. The skills that earned the promotion are not the skills the new job needs.

The book and the study, in three lines

Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull published The Peter Principle in 1969 as a satire on bureaucracy, with the line that every post tends to be occupied by an employee who is incompetent to carry out its duties. Fifty years later, Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue examined promotion records for sales workers across more than 200 US firms. Firms promoted on sales performance, and the best sellers, once promoted, led teams whose sales fell more than teams led by weaker sellers with better collaboration signals.

The joke had a mechanism, and the mechanism is a promotion bias. Companies pay for the old job and get the new one done badly.

Boomerang check: does your work stay delegated, or does it come back?

Three questions, scored to the protocol that fixes the leak. The 5-Minute Leader is the four protocols, Delegation, 1:1, Accountability and Rhythm, written down so a manager can run them in about five minutes a day, so tasks stop boomeranging back half done.

Get the 5-Minute Leader or see what is inside the 5-Minute Leader.

Three ways it shows up in a company

Who What they did before What they do now
The star closer, now sales manager Closed deals alone, worked the hardest, hated handing off Still closes the big deals herself, the team of eight waits, the team number drops
The best engineer, now engineering lead Wrote the cleanest code, fixed everything fast Reviews every pull request personally, becomes the bottleneck, ships less than before
The reliable operator, now head of operations Never missed a deadline, did every task well Keeps every task, delegates nothing, works 70 hour weeks and the team is idle

The pattern is identical. The person kept doing the old job harder, because that is what got rewarded, and nobody told them the new job was a different job.

The real mistake is not the promotion

Promoting the best performer is not wrong. The alternative, promoting someone worse at the work, has its own problems. The mistake is treating the promotion as proof of readiness instead of the start of training, and sending the new manager into day one with no method.

The new job has four parts the old job did not have, and all four can be taught in a week.

Handing work over. The star closer has to give the deals away, at 70 percent of how she would have done them, with the authority level stated so the rep does not come back to ask. This is the hardest part, because her identity is built on doing it herself. The how to delegate page is the method.

Running a weekly 1:1. Thirty minutes per person, their agenda first, one number question that tells her who is about to leave. Most new managers skip this because it feels like not working.

A daily rhythm. A 15 minute stand up and a weekly meeting with a scorecard, so she sees the team's number without chasing every rep.

The hard conversation. When the rep who was her peer last month misses the number, she needs a script, because the friendship will stop her saying it.

Give a new manager those four before day one and the Peter principle loses most of its force. The first time manager page is the 90 day version, and first time manager mistakes is the list of what happens without it.

For the person deciding who to promote

Three questions before the promotion, from the Benson, Li and Shue finding that collaboration signals predicted management results better than sales did.

Does this person already make the people around them better, and can you name one example. Has this person ever handed a piece of work over and let it stay handed over. Would this person rather be the best in the room or build the room. The answer to the third is the one the star closer usually gets wrong, and it is the one that matters. Should I become a manager is the version of that question for the candidate to read.

The method for the first 90 days

The Peter principle holds when the promotion comes with no method. The 5-Minute Leader is the method. I wrote it after scaling a company to more than 150 people and watching every one of my best individual performers struggle in their first year as managers, exactly as I had. Four protocols, Delegation, 1:1, Accountability and Rhythm, each run in about five minutes a day, so the new manager hands work over and it stays handed over.

The Delegation Protocol is the chapter for the star closer: the 70% Test, the three authority levels, the 3-Minute Delegation Conversation and the Delegation Board. The 1:1 Protocol is the weekly meeting with the one number question. The Accountability Protocol is the script for the conversation with the former peer. The Rhythm Protocol is the stand up and the weekly meeting.

There is one question in the 1:1 Protocol a new manager can ask in week one that tells her which rep she is about to lose, before the rep knows it.

Get the 5-Minute Leader

Peter principle FAQ

What is the Peter principle in simple terms?

The Peter principle says that in a hierarchy, people are promoted on the strength of their current job until they reach a job they cannot do, and there they stay. The best engineer becomes a manager because she was the best engineer, not because she can manage. Over time, every post tends to be filled by someone who has reached that level.

Who came up with the Peter principle?

Laurence J. Peter, a Canadian educator, with the writer Raymond Hull, in the 1969 book The Peter Principle. It was written as satire and read as truth. In 2019, Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue tested it on sales data from more than 200 firms and found that the best salespeople were promoted most and then had the worst team results.

What is an example of the Peter principle at work?

The top salesperson is promoted to sales manager. She closed deals by doing everything herself and now has eight people to run. She keeps closing deals herself, the eight wait, and the team's number falls. Nobody taught her that the manager's job is handing work over, so she does the old job harder and the new job not at all.

How do you avoid the Peter principle?

Promote for the next job, not the current one, and treat the first 90 days as training rather than proof. Give the new manager a handover method, a weekly 1:1 structure, a daily rhythm and a script for the hard conversation before day one. Most people can learn the job. They fail because nobody told them it was a different job.

Is the Peter principle real?

The mechanism is. Benson, Li and Shue showed that firms promote on current performance and that the resulting managers are measurably worse at the new job than people with lower sales and better management signals. Whether every post is eventually filled by someone incompetent, as the book joked, is satire. The promotion bias is not.

What is the difference between the Peter principle and the Dilbert principle?

The Peter principle says people rise until they reach a level they cannot handle. The Dilbert principle, a joke by Scott Adams, says companies deliberately promote their least competent people into management to get them away from the real work. One describes a bias in good faith promotions. The other is a cartoon.

Treat the promotion as day one of a new job

If you were just promoted, hand one piece of your old work over this week with the outcome, the level and a repeat back, and book a 30 minute 1:1 with each person. If you are deciding who to promote, ask the three things above. The Peter principle is a prediction about what happens with no method. It is not a sentence.

Which part of your old job are you still doing because you were the best at it?

Get the four protocols for the first 90 days.

Leadership insights, straight to your inbox

Practical protocols from a former Canon CEO. No fluff, unsubscribe anytime.

Andreas Pettersson

Andreas Pettersson

Former Canon CEO. Founded and exited Arcules, an AI company backed by Canon and Milestone. Today he coaches CEOs and executives through Leaders ADAPT.

More Posts

Free Leadership Profile & Style Assessments