By Andreas Pettersson, Founder, Leaders ADAPT
Four facts about trucking in one year. Truckload carriers averaged an operating margin of negative 2.3 percent in 2024. Costs then hit a record. Driver turnover ran at 44.2 percent. And the owner of a 40 truck fleet is still the person who answers the breakdown call in the middle of the night.
Then the loss. The fleet grows, the margin does not, and the owner's name is on every row of the dispatch board. That is the problem a trucking consultant rarely gets hired for.
Leaders ADAPT is my practice: private CEO coaching for owners, and a virtual mastermind with at most 14 members and no revenue gate, where logistics is one of the industries in the room. Before this I built a company past 150 people and exited it to Canon. This page is for owners of fleets of 10 to 200 trucks. It is not compliance advice and not startup consulting.
Leaders ADAPT on trucking consultants: A trucking consultant usually handles safety and compliance, carrier startup or lane profitability. Owners of 10 to 200 truck fleets often need something else: help building a management layer, pricing discipline and driver retention, which is the work of a trucking business coach or a peer group. Few publish prices. Smart Trucking lists consults from $49 for 15 minutes.
The three leadership problems of a fleet owner
A trucking consultant is an outside specialist hired for a defined trucking problem, while fleet owner coaching works on how the owner leads, prices and staffs the company as it grows. Most of what ranks for this search is compliance, startup and authority help. The three problems below are the ones the owner of an established fleet carries.
| Problem | What it looks like | The sourced fact | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Running hard, not making money | More trucks, more miles, the same or worse margin | Truckload averaged a negative 2.3 percent operating margin in 2024, and all in cost reached a record $2.336 per mile in 2025, up 3.4 percent, as reported by FreightWaves | ATRI and FreightWaves |
| The owner is still dispatcher, recruiter and safety manager | The fleet crossed 25 trucks and no manager layer was built | 90.2 percent of 787,189 active motor carriers run 10 or fewer power units, and only 7.2 percent run 11 to 100 | FMCSA Pocket Guide 2024 |
| Always hiring drivers | Every week starts with recruiting to replace last week's quits | Driver turnover was 44.2 percent overall in 2025 and 32 percent for fleets with fewer than 26 trucks, as reported by FreightWaves from ATRI data | FreightWaves |
The carriers agree. In the 2024 survey by the American Transportation Research Institute, motor carriers ranked driver shortage third and driver retention fifth among their top concerns, behind the economy and lawsuit abuse reform, with insurance fourth.
The second row explains the other two. Most carriers never get past ten trucks, so most owners never learn to build managers. The ones who do grow often grow the fleet without growing the leadership, and the dispatch board stays one person wide. The CEO coaching by industry hub lines this table up against the other industries.
What a trucking consultant solves, and what it does not
Trucking business consulting is good at defined problems. An audit coming, a safety rating to fix, a lane network to analyse, a technology rollout. If you know which system is broken, buy the specialist with a scope.
What it does not solve is the dispatch board with your name on every row.
A trucking business coach works on the owner's decisions behind the three rows. In a fleet of 10 to 200 trucks those are usually four.
Building the management layer. Dispatch, recruiting, safety and maintenance each need an owner who is not you. The benchmark that makes this concrete is old but clear. In the Truckload Carriers Association Profitability Program, using 2018 data, top fleets ran about 9 drivers per non driver against an industry average of 4.3, and the programme's average operating ratio was 90.40 percent. Treat it as dated. The direction still holds. The span of control calculator shows what one manager can carry.
Saying no to freight. When truckload margins are negative, more miles is not a strategy. Which lanes and customers do you drop? That is a pricing decision and a nerve decision, and the pricing strategy consultant page covers the method.
Retention as a job. If nobody owns driver retention, nobody does it. Someone has to watch why drivers leave and act on it weekly.
The owner's own seat. The owner who still takes the night call cannot also set the strategy for next year.
The limits are clear. A coach does not handle compliance, authority, insurance placement or legal. You need those specialists regardless.
What trucking consulting and coaching cost
Few trucking consultants publish prices. This is the public record.
| Option | Published price | Format | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smart Trucking consults | $49 for 15 minutes, $79 for 30 minutes, $149 for 45 minutes | Paid one on one calls for drivers and small owners | Smart Trucking |
| Forvis Mazars transportation consulting | Not published, contact or RFP | Profitability analysis and network consulting | Forvis Mazars |
| Scopelitis Transportation Consulting | Not published | Advisory and implementation from a trucking law firm's consulting arm | CCJ |
| Ahern and Associates mentoring | Flat annual fee, amount not published | Carriers assessed by former transportation company presidents and CEOs, reported in 2013 | Journal of Commerce |
| TCA Profitability Program | Not published | Peer benchmarking among carriers | FreightWaves |
| General CEO peer group | $2,500 joining fee plus $1,380 a month, about $19,060 in year one, as reported by Long Angle | Cross industry, $5 million revenue line | Long Angle |
The gap in that table is the middle. There are cheap calls for the one truck owner and enterprise consulting for large networks. For the owner of a 60 truck fleet who needs to stop being the dispatcher, there is very little published at all. Ask any trucking company consultant for the scope, the session count and the end date in writing.
Consultant, coach or peer group: how to choose
Start from the goal. If the goal is passing an audit, fixing a safety score or modelling a lane network, buy the consultant. If the goal is a company that makes money at 80 trucks and runs while you sleep, it is leadership work.
A coach fits the owner who knows the numbers and still cannot step out of dispatch. That is a habit and a trust problem. It takes months.
A peer group fits the owner who needs other owners to say it plainly. Industry benchmarking, like the TCA programme, shows where your numbers sit. A cross industry room, with owners from distribution, home services or lending, will ask why you are still answering the night line. A logistics business coach from inside the industry and an owner from outside will see different things. Both are useful.
My filter. Under 25 trucks, fix compliance and cash first, with specialists. From 25 to 100 trucks, the problem is the management layer, and a coach or peer group pays for itself in your own hours. Above 100 trucks, add a cadence that runs without you. The operating cadence page covers the weekly and monthly rhythm.
Industry veteran or operator from another industry
A trucking veteran knows lanes, deadhead, detention, the ELD and the way a dispatcher protects favourite drivers. For pricing and operations that knowledge is hard to replace.
An operator from another industry knows what happens to a company that hires fast. How to build a management team that runs functions. How to hand over hiring to someone else without losing quality. When to stop.
Three questions sort them quickly. What did you personally run, and how many people? How many of them did you hire yourself, and when did you stop? What did you do about the manager everyone complained about?
What hiring 30 people in three months taught me
When I was building my company, I hired 30 people in the first three months. By the end of year two we were at 70. More than 80 of the people we hired, I interviewed and hired personally.
That is how a fleet owner recruits drivers. Every week, personally, because nobody else can be trusted to judge. It works until it does not. The owner becomes the bottleneck on growth, and every other job, pricing, safety, customers, waits.
Later I ran operations across Europe, Japan and the US. You cannot dispatch three continents yourself. You build people who own the decision in their region and you accept that they will do it differently from you.
We scaled past 150 people. I did not get there by hiring faster. I got there by building the layer that hired for me. A fleet owner at 40 trucks is at the same point. The hire a COO page covers the first seat in that layer.
Coaching for the owner who is still on the night line
The 1:1 CEO coaching and advisory at Leaders ADAPT is one to one and I run it, as an operator who grew a company to more than 150 people and exited it to Canon. I do not do compliance, authority or insurance. I work with you on the management layer, the lanes you should drop, the retention job nobody owns, and your own seat.
Every session finishes with one commitment and a deadline. The first quarter usually goes to one hire.
It is not for a new carrier looking for authority or an owner preparing for an audit. Hire the specialist for that.
Trucking consultant FAQ
What does a trucking consultant do?
Most trucking consultants work on a defined area: safety and compliance, starting a new carrier, operating authority, network and lane profitability analysis, or technology. A trucking business coach works on a different problem, the owner, and how a fleet of 10 to 200 trucks is led, staffed and priced when the owner can no longer do every job personally.
How much does a trucking consultant cost?
Few publish prices. Smart Trucking lists one on one consults at $49 for 15 minutes, $79 for 30 minutes and $149 for 45 minutes, aimed at drivers and small owners. Forvis Mazars and Scopelitis Transportation Consulting quote per engagement. A 2013 report described a mentoring programme by Ahern and Associates at a flat annual fee that was not published.
Why are trucking companies losing money?
ATRI reported that in 2024 average operating margins were below 2 percent in every sector except less than truckload, and truckload averaged negative 2.3 percent. Costs then reached a record $2.336 per mile in 2025, up 3.4 percent, as reported by FreightWaves. Rates did not keep pace with costs, so many fleets ran more miles for less margin.
How do trucking companies reduce driver turnover?
Driver turnover was 44.2 percent across fleets in 2025 and 32 percent for fleets under 26 trucks, as reported by FreightWaves from ATRI data. Pay matters, but retention also depends on dispatch fairness, home time, how drivers are treated by their direct manager and whether someone owns retention as a job, which in small fleets is often nobody.
Is a trucking business coach the same as a compliance consultant?
No. A compliance consultant prepares a carrier for audits, safety ratings and regulations, and a startup consultant helps a new carrier get authority and first customers. A trucking business coach works with an established owner on leadership: building the management layer, pricing discipline, retention and the owner's own role. Most fleets need compliance help regardless.
When does a fleet owner need a management team?
FMCSA data shows 90.2 percent of carriers run 10 or fewer power units and 7.2 percent run 11 to 100, so most owners never build one. In TCA Profitability Program data from 2018, top fleets ran about 9 drivers per non driver against an industry average of 4.3. The ratio depends on having managers who own functions.
Clear the dispatch board this quarter
Before you call a trucking consultant, take last week's dispatch board, your recruiting log and your safety calls. Mark every decision that needed you. Then write next to each the role that should own it.
Count the rows. Name the first manager.
Which of those roles would you hand over this quarter, and who would you trust to take it?
Or test the answer with owners who have already built their layer.


